Charlotte Asks Judge to Dismiss Lawsuit Over Iryna Zarutska’s Blue Line Killing

0

The City of Charlotte is asking a judge to dismiss the wrongful death lawsuit filed over Iryna Zarutska’s killing on the LYNX Blue Line light rail.

City attorneys just filed the motion in Mecklenburg County Superior Court. They argue governmental immunity shields Charlotte from claims over transit policing, crime prevention and security decisions.

Zarutska, 23, was fatally stabbed aboard a CATS Blue Line train on Aug. 22, 2025.

Her estate sued Charlotte and Professional Security Services one year later. The lawsuit alleges inadequate security, weak fare enforcement and other failures made her death preventable.

The city says decisions involving police deployment and transit security are governmental functions protected under North Carolina law. It also invokes the “public-duty doctrine,” arguing police protection is generally a duty owed to the public rather than one individual.

Charlotte also argues the stabbing itself broke the legal chain of responsibility. Attorneys describe Decarlos Brown Jr.’s alleged attack as an independent criminal act the city did not cause.

Charlotte says Zarutska boarded at Scaleybark Station around 9:46 p.m. and was stabbed roughly four minutes later. The city also acknowledges no private security guard was inside that specific train car at the time.

The city further acknowledges Brown appeared to board the train without presenting a ticket or pass. CATS operates the Blue Line as an open-platform, proof-of-payment system without turnstiles.

If the judge allows any claims against Charlotte to continue, the city is asking the court to enforce a cumulative $1 million payment limit tied to its governmental immunity rules.

The family’s lawsuit seeks damages exceeding $25,000, along with other compensation permitted by law. It also seeks punitive damages from the private security contractor.

The dismissal request now puts one of Charlotte’s most closely watched transit-safety cases before a Mecklenburg County judge.